Old bad ….. new bad


Talking with colleagues this morning I found myself reflecting on old bad and new bad. A variation on new wine in old bottles. The conversation was about our efforts at the council to be mobile and agile in our work styles. The point being made was that our current workplace culture and the trappings that go with it – hierarchy, furnishings, systems and procedures – are maybe bad, i.e. worn out or “no longer fit for purpose” (as we are all obliged to say these days). So we introduce new ones, mobile and agile, IT based, work  “a place we go” being replaced by work “a thing we do” as our creed.

The issue for colleagues was that some aspects of the new, the mobile and agile,  are not fit for purpose from the get go for some. For example, the systems (IT and otherwise) aren’t up to scratch and so the mobile/agile thing can’t happen as intended. And for many for whom it does work from the start line well, things may become unsuitable as time goes by as new systems and capabilities come along rendering the new old and no longer fit for purpose – there I go again.

This resonated with me on the back of a radio interview I heard this morning about Tesco’s losses which were attributed by the interviewee to their failure to carry on innovating. In the 1990s into 2000s they were market leaders, the first with so many things – Clubcard, home delivery, class leading customer care, new product items and so on. In the last  few years they have stagnated while others have caught up and passed them in the innovation game, and on price perhaps – better for less, what’s not to like?

In the public service we have to be continuous innovators too. Keep things under review, be “endlessly restless” as a colleague’s blog proclaims.  The last reorganisation or big idea is not and cannot be the last reorganisation or big idea.  The solution to today’s problems will not be the solution to the problems of tomorrow. They will all become no longer fit for purpose eventually. And bad is always bad – new or old.


One thought on “Old bad ….. new bad

  1. Hi Richard, We carried out some breakfast briefings recently around how clients were looking at approaching transformation and channel shift and we captured answers to about 8 questions we posed. We then created a “Top 3” of things to do before we could embark on opening up services and transactional processes. The first was to understand what you have already in place, what it can do and what role it plays in end to end process; second was transform the back office and improve processes and third was integration in the back office. Link systems together so that when you look to start opening up processes the systems are linked in the most efficient way.

    Reading your Council Plan and the section on Transformation this seems to ring true. I would be interested in sharing the outcomes and information on this if you feel it is relevant.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s